Past All-Tournament Team Members
June 18, 2009
| 1996 | 1997 | 1998 |
| Cody Gerdes, Saunemin | Benjy Kennedy, Pont. Ap. | Mike Berry, Tri-Point |
| Tommy Green, St. Marys | Kyle Soule, Pont. Christian | Craig Roberts, Pont. Ap. |
| Ryan Carley, Pont. Christian | Chad Hobbs, Ridgeview | Robert Verdun, Pont. Ap. |
| Andrew Weber, Pont. Chr. | Andrew Stoltz, Ridgeview | Drew Bauer, St. Marys |
| Andy Vitzthum, Pont. Ap. | Ryan Sheets, Holy Trinity A | Jonathon Schulz, Mazon |
| Andy Kasprzak, Holy Trinity | Mike Donovan, Graymont/Es | Matt Spaniol, Woodland |
| Brandon Miller, Tri-Point | Ryan Shaughnessy, Gray/Esm | Dave Hjerpe, Woodland |
| Eric Immke, Saunemin | Casey Casson, St. Marys 6 | Kyle Donnelly, Holy Trinity |
| Cory Gerdes, Saunemin | Ryan Benning, St. Marys 5 | Corey Harbor, Dwight |
| Raymond Lello Holy Trinity B | Eric Giovanini, St. Marys 5 | |
| 1999 | 2000 | 2001 |
| Kyle Lowe, Saunemin | Jimmy Jardine, Saunemin | Troy Brown, Saunemin |
| Michael Kellar, Ridgeview | Rayme Mackinson, Pont. Ap. | Danny Pfoff, Ridgeview |
| Alex Roth, Gridley | Doug Connor, Holy Trinity A | Trevor Trhlik, Ridgeview |
| Kyle Austin, Tri-Point | Alex Arbogast, St. Marys 6 | Alex Diller, Prairie Central |
| John Johns, St. Marys 6 | Brian Lambert, St. Marys 6 | Andrew Hinnenkamp, HT B |
| Philip Giles, Pont. Christian | Miles Morris, Leroy | Zach Lauer, Holy Trinity A |
| Eric Giovanini, St. Marys 6 | Andrew Lenahan, Holy Tri. B | Phillip Rich, Pont. Comanches |
| Clay Harbor, Dwight | Shawn Jensen, Pont. Christian | Travis Misener, Mazon |
| Shane Davis, Holy Trinity A | Chris Newsome, Pont. Chr. | Colton Tambling, Dwight |
| Brian Lambert, St. Marys 5 | Stephen Krominga, St. Marys | Patrick Miller, St. Marys 5 |
| 2002 | 2003 | 2004 |
| Chris Christensen, Gardner | Zack Stadel, Odell | Jacob Yates, Saunemin |
| Mike Panno, St. Marys 5 | Caleb Buscher, Pont. Chr. | Marty Schulz, St. Marys 5 |
| Billy Toohill, Leroy | Zack Sorensen, Gardner | Mitchell McDonald, Pr. Cent. |
| Pete Kinate, Prairie Central | Paul Panno, St. Marys 5 | Jason Karstens, Dwight |
| Paul Tolan, Ridgeview | Dan Curran, Holy Trinity | Dillon Harris, Dwight |
| Aaron Coile, Ridgeview | Jeremy Fagan, Tri-Point | Casey Wyllie, Dwight |
| Alex Smith, St. Marys 6 | Bradley Ghere, Ridgeview | Matt Starker, Pontiac Com. |
| Patrick Miller, St. Marys 6 | Tyler Bruening, Leroy | Ryan Crowley, St. Marys 6 |
| Jeff Collier, Holy Trinity | Matt Schoop, Leroy | Drew Duffy, Flanagan |
| Patrick Kniery, Holy Trinity | Michael Panno, St. Marys 6 | Cody Leach, Flanagan |
| 2005 | 2006 | 2007 |
| Oliver Moews, Holy Trinity 5 | Kyle Crowley, St. Marys 5 | Addison Bounds, Prairie Cent. |
| Pete Martin, St. Marys 6 | Matt Mogged, Tri-Point | Evan Vint, Mazon |
| Dylan Stout, Saunemin | Caleb Leach, Flanagan | Corey Winterland, Ridgeview |
| Josh Wilson, Pontiac Com. | Tim Tjarks, St. Marys 6 | William Meiner, St. Marys 6 |
| David Babb, Pontiac Com. | Mark Panno, St. Marys 6 | Kyle Crowley, St. Marys 6 |
| Shawn Kinkade, Tri-Point | Kasey Newlin, Pontiac Ap. | Jon Roberts, Pontiac Ap. |
| Kevin Rollins, Normal Epiph. | Aaron Boma, Dwight | Devan Maurer, Pont. Christian |
| Jesse King, Pontiac Apaches | Jack Steichen, Dwight | Elliot Hoerdemann, Holy Tr. 5 |
| Taylor O'Connor, St. Marys 6 | Alex Arnold, Holy Trinity 6 | Mitch Haynes, Holy Trinity 6 |
| Chase Alford, Pontiac Ap. | Oliver Moews, Holy Trinity 6 | Nick Schroeder, Holy Trin. 6 |
| 2008 | 2009 | 2010 |
| Christian Fannin, Ridgeview | Andy Brockman, Holy Trinity | TBA |
| Devin Leo, Mazon | Brian David, Mazon | |
| Austin Hasslebring, Cres. City | Neil Lambert, St. Marys 6 | |
| Drew Mills, St. Marys 5 | Kyle Eggenberger, Pont. Chr. | |
| Elliot Hoerdemann, Holy Tr. 6 | Caleb Boma, Dwight | |
| Cole Fairley, Prairie Central | Tyler Carley, Pont. Christian | |
| Alex Kohlmeier, Pontiac Ap. | Luke Ward, Ridgeview | |
| Trent Smith, Pontiac Apaches | Carter Jacobs, St. Marys 6 | |
| Luke Kownick, Holy Trinity 6 | Drew Mills, St. Marys 6 | |
| Kyle Tucker, Odell | Grant Bachtold, Pr. Central |
